Children are increasingly using smartphones and tablets to access the internet, raising concerns about their safety online. Currently, app stores and developers bear minimal legal responsibility for the protection of these young users. This year, Congress is set to address this issue with the introduction of the App Store Accountability Act. This bipartisan legislation, put forward by Senator Mike Lee (UT) and Representative John James (MI) in May, aims to close regulatory gaps that enable children to download applications, make in-app purchases, and accept terms of service agreements without parental approval.
Contents
Closing Regulatory Gaps
The proposed act aims to rectify loopholes that allow children to engage with apps and make purchases without the necessary consent from their guardians. It also seeks to regulate how app developers assign age ratings, ensuring that false claims do not go unpunished. The legislation is inspired by a model developed by the Digital Childhood Alliance (DCA), a coalition of over 100 child advocacy organizations, including those aligned with Focus on the Family. The DCA contends that the bill will align app stores and developers with U.S. contract law, which mandates that all contract parties be at least 18 years old and provide informed consent.
Concerns Surrounding App Stores
According to the DCA, app stores serve as digital gatekeepers for children’s online experiences but often inflict harm by treating minors as adults, allowing them to agree to potentially exploitative contracts with large corporations. The organization points out that app stores are rarely held accountable for misleading age ratings, and they frequently obscure vital information, such as app content descriptions, making it nearly impossible for parents to provide informed consent.
Unseen Risks in Unregulated Apps
The absence of regulation in apps and app stores not only bypasses parental oversight but also removes essential protections for children online. Parental controls on devices do not adequately filter content within apps. Furthermore, age ratings are often unreliable, as app developers are responsible for setting them. For instance, TikTok previously rated its app as suitable for ages 12 and up, but Apple recommended a change to 17 and older after discovering that the app featured “frequent or intense mature and suggestive content,” a request that TikTok declined. Advertisements within games aimed at young audiences can also present violent or pornographic material, along with links to unfiltered internet searches.
Legislative Framework of the App Store Accountability Act
The App Store Accountability Act proposes requiring app stores and developers to obtain explicit parental consent before engaging with minors. The legislation consists of two main parts. The first mandates that app stores conduct age-verification checks for users who download apps and inform developers of any underage users. Developers would be required to request age re-verification annually or whenever there are concerns about account security. The second part of the legislation enhances accountability for app stores and developers, requiring them to secure parental consent before allowing minors to download or make purchases within an app. Additionally, parents would need to be notified when an app monetizes features, alters data collection practices, or changes its age rating.
Incentives for Compliance
While the App Store Accountability Act provides legal immunity to developers if an app store fails to verify user ages, this exemption only applies to those who can demonstrate a genuine effort to protect young users from harmful content. This creates a significant legal motivation for developers to prioritize child safety, even if such measures are not explicitly mandated by the law.
State-Level Initiatives
Several states, including Utah, Texas, and Louisiana, have enacted their own App Store Accountability laws, based on the DCA’s model legislation. These laws empower affected families to take legal action against app stores and developers for breaches. In Ohio, lawmakers introduced a similar bill in April, while Alabama’s attempt to pass such legislation faced strong opposition from major tech companies and e-commerce platforms.
Why This Legislation is Crucial
While it is ultimately the responsibility of parents to safeguard their children online, they should be equipped with the necessary tools to do so effectively. The lack of regulation among app stores and developers complicates the efforts of even the most diligent parents to protect their children from harmful online content. The Daily Citizen supports any legislative measures that empower parents in their protective roles.
Follow me to stay updated on the latest technology and computer news from around the world. Join me in spreading the love for tech!